When investors want a quick sense of whether a stock looks cheap or expensive, they often reach for valuation ratios. Two of the most widely used are the price-to-earnings ratio and the price-to-book ratio. Both compare a company’s share price with a measure of its fundamentals, but they look at very different things and work better in different situations. Used thoughtfully, they can be helpful starting points. Used mechanically, they can be seriously misleading.
This article explains how each ratio works, when each tends to be most useful, their limitations, and how to combine them with other analysis.
The Price-to-Earnings Ratio
The price-to-earnings ratio, usually called the P/E ratio, compares a company’s share price with its earnings per share.
P/E ratio = Share price ÷ Earnings per share
If a company’s shares trade at $40 and it earned $2 per share over the past year, its P/E ratio is 20. Put another way, investors are paying $20 for every $1 of annual earnings.
Trailing versus forward P/E
- Trailing P/E uses earnings from the most recent twelve months. It is based on actual results but looks backward.
- Forward P/E uses estimated earnings for the coming year. It looks ahead but depends on forecasts, which can be wrong.
Earnings yield
Flipping the P/E ratio gives the earnings yield: earnings per share divided by price. A P/E of 20 equals an earnings yield of 5%. Some investors find the yield easier to compare with interest rates on bonds or savings accounts, though the comparison is imperfect because earnings are not paid out in full and can change.
The Price-to-Book Ratio
The price-to-book ratio, or P/B ratio, compares a company’s market value with its book value, which is the accounting value of its assets minus its liabilities, as shown on the balance sheet.
P/B ratio = Share price ÷ Book value per share
If a company’s book value is $25 per share and its shares trade at $50, its P/B ratio is 2. Investors are paying twice the accounting value of the company’s net assets.
What Each Ratio Tells You
The P/E ratio focuses on profitability. It tells you how the market values a company’s earning power. The P/B ratio focuses on the balance sheet. It tells you how the market values the company’s net assets.
A high P/E may suggest that investors expect strong earnings growth, or that the stock is expensive, or that current earnings are temporarily depressed. A low P/E may suggest a bargain, or that investors expect earnings to decline, or that the business faces serious risks.
A P/B ratio below 1 means the market values the company at less than its accounting net worth. That can signal undervaluation, but it can also reflect doubts about the true value of the assets or about the company’s ability to earn adequate returns on them. A high P/B ratio often appears in companies whose value comes largely from intangible assets or high returns on capital.
When Each Ratio Tends to Be Most Useful
P/E ratio
The P/E ratio is generally most useful for companies with stable, positive earnings. It is less helpful when earnings are negative, when they swing wildly from year to year, or when they are distorted by one-time gains or charges.
P/B ratio
The P/B ratio is often more relevant for businesses whose assets are mostly financial or tangible and are recorded at values close to their economic worth. Banks and insurers are common examples, because their balance sheets consist largely of loans, securities, and other financial assets. It tends to be less meaningful for companies whose most valuable assets, such as brands, software, patents, or customer relationships, are not fully reflected on the balance sheet.
The Link Between the Two Ratios
The two ratios are connected through return on equity, which measures how much profit a company earns relative to its book value.
P/B ratio = P/E ratio × Return on equity
Consider a hypothetical example. A company with a P/E of 15 and a return on equity of 20% would have a P/B ratio of 3. Another with the same P/E but a return on equity of only 5% would have a P/B ratio of 0.75. The relationship shows why a low P/B ratio is not automatically attractive: a company earning poor returns on its assets may deserve a low valuation relative to book value.
Limitations of the P/E Ratio
- Earnings can be manipulated or distorted. Accounting choices, one-time items, and adjustments can make earnings look better or worse than the underlying business.
- Cyclical companies can mislead. At the peak of a business cycle, earnings may be unusually high, making the P/E look low just before profits fall. At the bottom, the P/E may look high when earnings are temporarily depressed.
- Debt is ignored. Two companies with the same P/E can carry very different levels of debt, which affects risk.
- Growth is not captured directly. A higher P/E may be justified for a company with strong, durable growth.
Limitations of the P/B Ratio
- Intangible assets are often missing. Internally developed brands, technology, and know-how may not appear on the balance sheet.
- Asset values may be outdated. Some assets are recorded at historical cost, which may differ significantly from current market value.
- Share buybacks can reduce book value. Companies that repurchase large amounts of stock can have very high or even negative book values, making the ratio hard to interpret.
- Accounting standards differ. Comparisons across countries or industries can be distorted by different accounting rules.
Comparing Ratios Sensibly
Valuation ratios are most meaningful in context. Useful comparisons include:
- Against the company’s own history, to see whether it is valued higher or lower than usual, and why.
- Against close competitors, since different industries naturally carry different typical ratios.
- Against the broader market, keeping in mind that market-wide valuations also shift over time.
In each case, the important question is why a difference exists. A lower ratio may reflect a genuine opportunity or a real problem the market has already noticed.
A Practical Approach
- Choose the ratio that best fits the type of business you are analyzing.
- Check whether earnings or book value are distorted by unusual items.
- Look at the ratio over several years and compare it with peers.
- Consider growth, return on equity, and debt alongside the ratio.
- Ask what expectations the current price implies and whether they seem reasonable.
- Use ratios as a screen to identify companies for deeper research, not as a final verdict.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a good P/E ratio?
There is no universal answer. Typical ratios vary by industry, growth rate, interest rates, and market conditions. A ratio that seems high for a slow-growing utility might be reasonable for a fast-growing company, and vice versa.
Is a P/B ratio below 1 always a bargain?
No. It may reflect poor profitability, questionable asset values, or significant risks. Further research is needed to understand why the market values the company below book value.
Should I use these ratios for companies with losses?
The P/E ratio is not meaningful when earnings are negative. Investors in such cases often look at other measures, such as revenue-based ratios, cash flow, or the path to profitability.
Valuation ratios condense a lot of information into a single number, which is both their strength and their weakness. Treat them as questions rather than answers: each one points you toward the assumptions and facts you need to understand before deciding whether a stock is truly cheap or expensive.
This article is for general educational purposes only and does not constitute investment, tax, or legal advice. Investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal. Consider your own circumstances and consult a qualified professional before making financial decisions.